Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Elise's avatar

I say this as often as I can about trans kids, as you have, that what “we are doing to them right now is child abuse.” It is. Plain and simple. Living in the deep south I find I must pay attention to what room I’m in when I say it, but that doesn’t stop me from building a better room.

“… our responsibility is to those who lack power, not those who hold it.”

Sheila Grace Newsom's avatar

James-It seems so important that you have a recognition that the tie and the choker were never opposites. The courtroom Dale and the Queer Nation Dale were not false self and true self, they were different expressions of the same person responding intelligently to different fields and neither exhausted the person who wore them.

That takes me somewhere deeper than identity or even “beingness.” It takes me toward soul.

Something in a human life always exceeds what can be said about it. And therefore, a human soul is not speech, it is not an argument or an ideology and it cannot be reduced to the banner someone places around its neck, exhausted by a category, or finally captured by analyst, government (especially governemnt!), religion, diagnosis or even by an individual’s present understanding of herself.

The soul remains larger than any formulation we make of it.

But there is a necessary premise beneath all of this: freedom. There must be sufficient freedom for a human being to explore what is trying to become known, to try on the tie and the choker, to enter different rooms, to discover what belongs and what does not, to change, to contradict oneself, and ultimately to become more fully one’s own.

For all of its profound failures to live up to the promise, that freedom has been one of the great ideals of the America in which I grew up: not that everyone must agree about who I am, but that there is an interior territory of human life into which neither government nor majority nor institution can presume to intrude.

That is why your essay feels to me as though it is about considerably more than the word queer. The danger begins when we stop arguing about how people may live together and begin presuming to decide which forms of human self-discovery are legitimate in the first place.

Your line from Evan Wolfson: “a human being is certainly not speech” reaches toward something even deeper for me:

A human soul is not speech.

It needs room to reveal itself.

And a free society, at its best, protects that sacred room. Sheila Grace

7 more comments...

Ready for more?