The path started at Harmony Elementary and ran along the edge of the woods, past the sports fields where I kept the bench warm and past Thorne Middle School. Even though it was the fastest way home, I almost never took it. The path terrified me. Well, not the path really; it was the woods.
That day, walking to Miss Hand’s sixth-grade class, I heard it.
“Hey, dicky boy.” I knew the voice before I saw the face.
“Today’s the day,” he said. “After school, don’t run, ’cause we’ll find you. We know where you live.”
Suddenly my feet sped up. My heart was ticking like a timer duct-taped to a bundle of dynamite. Then I was seated in the classroom. All-day anxiety crawled through my bones. My sweat stank with fear.
My knapsack was already packed when the school bell rang at 3:00 pm. I ran out the back door, across the dodgeball circles painted on the black asphalt, past the jungle gym made of threadbare tires, and onto the dirt path. It was the fastest way home. I had no idea where they were. Were they hiding in the woods behind the towering oak trees? I only remember my feet moving as fast as they could. There was no thought, just instinct, action, and terror.
Where were the safe homes? My neighborhood had them. A large piece of colored construction paper would be visible in their front window with a red handprint on it. Any child in trouble could knock, and somebody would take them into safety. I knew where the signs were, but I couldn’t trust them. Some of those houses belonged to the families of boys who terrified me. So, I ran past those houses to my home on Lisa Lane. Nobody was there. I reached for my key, but it was missing.
I don’t remember what happened next. I recall searching for an unlocked door or window, but there were none. Then I saw the basement window at ground level, on the side of my house. I remember a brick and shattered glass and then my hand going through it. I opened the latch, pushed open the window, and climbed down to the floor. There I hid, curled in the fetal position on the broken glass, shaking on the concrete floor. Safe next to the model railroad with Lionel trains and mold.
I never fessed up to smashing our basement window. My parents thought it was one of the neighborhood bullies. One Mischief Night, neighborhood kids threw a brick through our front window with a smoke bomb taped to it. The carpet in the living room still has a melted burn stain where the fibers caught fire.
My parents never understood my terror, and they weren’t great about discussing feelings. They thought I should toughen up and fight back as my brother did. But he was much taller and older for his grade, while I was the youngest in my class. Mom and Dad signed me up for karate classes and told me to go to the gym at the nearby U.S. Racquetball Club. That’s where I fell in love with aerobics classes instead.
Back on Lisa Lane, nobody came after me. Nobody chased me across that path or through the broken window into my empty house. I was a latchkey kid who lost his key.
I ran the whole way home from a threat that stayed exactly where I’d left it, back by the woods. I smashed open a window to find safety from a boy and a gang who never followed me. Sometimes the woods were empty; sometimes they weren’t. They didn’t always have the energy to chase me. They just liked to terrorize me. I let them steal my childhood with my anxiety. That boy in the basement thought he was protecting himself. He wanted to survive. He wanted to be old enough to get away, and he did.
I’ve been thinking about that window this past summer, since another child stood in front of a camera and told the country he was watching Scouting closely.
United States Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth posted a six-minute victory-lap video on Friday, February 27th, 2026, announcing that he’d forced Scouting America (formerly the Boy Scouts of America), the organization that once expelled me for being gay, to purge what he called “an insidious, radical, woke ideology.” He gave Scout leaders six months to prove themselves. He closed with a threat that sounded a lot like the one I heard in sixth grade:
“We’re watching, and we’re watching closely.”
I filed a FOIA for the memorandum of understanding that Hegseth kept waving around on TV. His Pentagon stonewalled, so I appealed. Then the DoD appeals chief kicked it back to the same office that had stalled it, with no deadline. She told me my remedy was federal court. That’s what I did.
I sued in federal court with one lawyer, and weeks later they handed over all six pages. The man who was watching closely could not handle being watched.

I’ve thought about the Boy Scout in the basement more than I thought I would this summer. He didn’t know, crouched there shaking on the concrete, that nobody was coming after him. He’d already done the damage: the broken window, a cut hand, his pounding heart, trauma, all of it spent on a chase that existed in his own insecurities.
Don’t hand them the power. Don’t run. Don’t hide.
I haven’t walked that path since middle school. A few years ago, when I was 51, I went back to that field with Mike De Socio, a reporter and gay former Eagle Scout whom I had never met in person. He was writing a book about the evolution of scouting, and he wanted to revisit the places where my scouting career happened.
I stood on the sidewalk of Murphy Road at the edge of the sports field; there was the worn path I ran home across in terror far too often. The mighty maples and the ash trees were now dying from some disease. The woods looked so sparse I don’t see how anybody could hide in them anymore. And still, standing there, the terror came back to me. The sadness. The loneliness of being that child running home to an empty house and hiding in the basement.
I didn’t want Mike to see me that vulnerable and insecure. So, I performed with a stiff upper lip. The Gay Boy Scout, on stage again, while I tucked away whatever I was feeling. I performed like I was taught to, to survive.
Pretending to be straight. Pretending not to feel the hate.
As an adult, I learned the power of my journey when I shared my emotions and ripped them out to tell America how painful the Scouts’ bigotry was to me. For over a decade, I shared strategic vulnerability. I tapped into my emotions, the pain and the struggle, and showed the world what it felt like. I inspired Americans to expect more from their institutions, whether the White House, the Supreme Court, or the Boy Scouts of America. But with Mike on that day, looking across the sports field, it was too raw, too fresh to share with a stranger there to write about my fight.
I hadn’t worked through the emotions enough to share with him then, but I hope he’ll read this. Mike wrote an amazing book, Morally Straight: How the Fight for LGBTQ+ Inclusion Changed the Boy Scouts—and America. He did justice to the fight. He did justice to my story. Today Mike’s a friend living his best life in Italy. I have my copy of his book right here.

I hope you’ll buy it too, though.
I had never told anyone the truth about that window. Not then, not since. On Sunday I had lunch with my mom and said nothing. Yesterday I called her while she was shopping for discount groceries at Lidl and made my 45-year-old confession. Just the window, not this piece. She said she’s crawled through basement windows too. She laughed it off. My parents are good people, and they did the best they could.
The scars never really leave you. Terror is permanently etched into your DNA.
I’m not going to let Pete Hegseth bully kids in Scouting. Not on my watch.
I urged Scouting America to use my lawsuit and challenge the Department of Defense back in March in Time Magazine. They didn’t say anything at all, but slowly, anything DEI-related started to disappear. Scouting is a values-based organization. Their values expelled me in 1990, and then the Supreme Court agreed in 2000.
Scouting America, this is 2026. Where are your values now? Show America you still have values, and that you will protect Scouts in your care: LGBTQ kids, girls, and kids of color.
I refuse to run from little boys like Pete. I’m done pretending these people are anything more than sick charlatans and showmen.
Cage fights on the White House lawn? Seriously, these people have access to the nuclear codes?
Stare them down. Look right in their eyes and see what happens. In my experience, they’re usually already backing away, hoping you won’t turn around.
And Petie, if you do decide to run for president, look for me on the campaign trail too, sweetie.
Thanks for reading. If you liked what you read here, I hope you subscribe to my Substack or follow me at jamesrdale.com.


James, My comment said “Mike”. My fingers did that on their own. So,
James, Keep up the fight. As an 81+ year old gay man, I have fought many battles and seem to have to continue. I call them “The Rainbow Battles”. Thanks, Michael
Dale, Thanks for continuing the battle. As an 81+ year old, I have fought many. I call them “The Rainbow Battles”. Fondyl, Michael