I recently sat down with Spencer Macnaughton at Uncloseted Media to talk about the fight over Scouting America’s future. We covered my Supreme Court case, the loss, and the grassroots movement over Scouting’s values. Then we pivoted to the strange position of watching a government official try to pressure a private organization into changing its values. Transgender youths are targeted in Scouting America changes pushed by the Pentagon.
Everyone wants to discuss the lawsuit, the arguments, and the outcome. But there’s a part of this story nobody asks about.
No one asks what Scouting actually felt like when it was working.
Secretary Pete Hegseth was never a Scout. So let me bring him up to speed.
⸻
In the summer of 1985, I was 14 and alone at Forestburg Scout Reservation up in the Catskills. Troop 128 was falling apart, and the few scouts who’d come to camp had already gone home. I wanted to stay another week.
On a quiet Saturday afternoon, I walked past a small lodge near the ranger’s house and heard a synthetic drumbeat and the squeal of a saxophone blasting from a champagne-silver Sanyo boombox: “Baby Jane.”
A Scout I’d never seen before was stretched out in an Adirondack chair, having his own private dance party.
He saw me and turned the music down.
“Sorry, I didn’t know anyone was still here. I’m Ahmed.”
His uniform was a darker green than mine. Different cut. Different patches. He didn’t look like anyone from Monmouth County, New Jersey, or anywhere near it.
Ahmed was an exchange Scout from Egypt, passing through Forestburg on his way to the US National Jamboree.
He handed me a cassette case, twelve identical Rod Stewarts in a red pleather suit.
Over the next week, we became friends, and he convinced me to stay on as camp staff. He didn’t fit in, and he didn’t try to. He liked the attention. He liked being different. He liked the freedom of being in America.
We spent afternoons on that porch, rewinding tapes with yellow #2 pencils, discussing music and talking about places I could only imagine.
No one arranged it. No one supervised it. Two kids ended up in the same place, and that was enough.
It was one of the best summers of my life.
⸻
Around that same time, I was deep into the Order of the Arrow, Scouting’s honor society. I led the ceremonies team. We inducted new members through rituals we believed honored Native American traditions.
We wore feathered headdresses and face paint. We thought we were being respectful, following the script and setting the scenes.
At 14, I didn’t question it.
Then an advisor pulled me aside.
He told me the headdresses we wore had nothing to do with the Lenape tribe we claimed to honor. The Lenape lived in the Northeast, along the Delaware River. What we were doing was something else. We cobbled together different cultures like Frankenstein.
“If your parents agree,” he said, “I’d like to take you to New York City. There’s a museum they’re about Native American culture. We can learn what we’re actually trying to represent.”
So we went.
I was hooked. I spent weekends reading, sketching, and asking questions. My mother and I remade the regalia from scratch on her Singer Futura sewing machine.
Looking back, maybe we got closer. But it still wasn’t ours to get right.
⸻
A couple of years later, I was 16 and chairing the Vigil Honor committee, the group that selected candidates for the Order of the Arrow’s highest recognition.
A name came up.
He was in his late thirties. Single. Flamboyant. Completely devoted to Scouting. He was my scoutmaster.
Someone in the room said what many were thinking: “he’s gay,” implying he didn’t belong.
I wasn’t out. I didn’t have words for what I was yet. At the height of the AIDS crisis, I was terrified of everything gay.
But I spoke anyway.
“This isn’t about whether he’s gay or not,” I said. “This is about what he’s done for this lodge and our council. This is about brotherhood.”
The room went quiet.
When the vote was cast, he was elected.
Later, my Scoutmaster told me it was one of the greatest honors of his life.
I didn’t stand up because I thought of it as inclusion. I didn’t know that language. I stood up because I believed what I’d been taught. You stand by people, especially when it’s inconvenient.
Those words were already in me before I knew why they mattered.
⸻
That’s the part people miss.
The Scouting I grew up in didn’t need to be told to do these things. It already did them.
It put me on a porch with a kid from Cairo.
It sent me to a museum to learn something I’d gotten wrong.
It put me in a room where I had to decide, in real time, what “brotherhood” actually meant.
No policy. No program. Just practice.
The inclusion of trans Scouts and girls isn’t a break from Scouting’s traditions. It’s what happens when you take those same values seriously.
Hegseth calls it “woke.” But I know it’s what Scouting was always about.
I hope you’ll check out the entire Uncloseted Media interview here.
