A few weeks ago, I was on Fire Island, staring out the window at the ocean and the dune and the grass. This is my happy place. I set up my laptop and got on a Zoom call with another writer to discuss activism and whether we might collaborate.
Somewhere in the middle of the conversation, Fire Island Pines came up. I came on hot. My adrenaline was running high after suing the Pentagon a few days earlier. I felt the same passion and purpose I had when I sued the Scouts 36 years ago, when I was a 19-year-old college student. Under the guise of masculinity, Pete Hegseth and his Pentagon are bullying children: girls, gays, and trans kids.
Our Zoom started with me telling the other writer how much I admired his thinking. We both agree on a united queer community, and it’s imperative that we work together and leverage our privilege for others. But we didn’t agree on Fire Island. My favorite place in the world.
I was enthusiastic. He was reserved. I was trying to convince him, but it wasn’t working. I could see it in his expression. The further he slipped away from me, the harder I tried.
He told me he came to the Pines once and stayed in a rental house for a few days. He said the community never felt welcoming. He is sober, and to him, the Pines was one never-ending party: all surface, no depth. After a single weekend, he had soured on the whole place. I pushed back harder than I expected, defending the community I love with my entire being.
The first time I came to Fire Island was 1993. I didn’t share this story on our Zoom call.
I was the Gay Boy Scout and a Lambda Legal plaintiff early in my lawsuit against America’s most beloved institution. Lambda brought me out to speak at two fundraisers. One in Cherry Grove, at the home of the legendary drag performer Rose Levine. Then later there was a sit-down dinner in the Pines. I was shuttled between the two queer communities by private boat on the Great South Bay, wearing an olive Nautica polo and chino shorts I found at a thrift shop. I stood in beautiful houses full of men who seemed nothing like me. Most of my family vacations were at KOA Campgrounds in a pop-up trailer. I felt out of place.
When I finished speaking, the party resumed. A few people came up to share their Boy Scout stories. It felt like they were looking for my approval, and it made me uneasy. I found it difficult to even make eye contact. It’s always been easier to speak from a stage than to the audience afterward, where I had to process emotions … mine and theirs. I was the featured speaker at the two parties. But I wasn’t quite a guest.
So, when the other writer told me Fire Island wasn’t for him, I understood. I have been ferrying out to the Pines and the Grove for over thirty years, and I have felt almost every possible way about the place.
In the 90s, I was somebody’s weekend guest. In the 2000s, after I lost in the Supreme Court, I was a renter in “share houses.” When I finally spent real time here in my late forties, I found a community unlike anything I have experienced. Maybe I finally accepted myself and became comfortable in my own skin. Here in the Pines, I could be the queer person I’ve always wanted to be. Free from the judgment that I’m too effeminate, too this or not enough that. I have lived in New York, San Francisco, and London, and I have been lucky enough to travel to gay enclaves around the world, from Russian River to Mykonos. I’ve never found another place like Fire Island.
I tried to share that. I told him I knew what it felt like to feel disconnected from Fire Island, but I encouraged him to give it a second chance. I invited him to my house as my guest without even asking my partner first.
“I’ll show you a side of the Pines you’ve never seen before. I’ll introduce you to my friends and other amazing people here.” I thought of Rose Levine, the oldest living drag performer at 93; Jim Pepper, who co-founded the Stonewall Community Foundation; and Eric Sawyer, who was a founding member of ACT UP and Housing Works. They are my heroes. “Please, be my guest,” I encouraged him. It went unacknowledged. He said nothing. That was in the middle of the call, and I tried to fill the silence. I spoke faster, trying to win him over.
I keep thinking about it. I have sober friends who love Fire Island and have found their way to be here. I can’t imagine how hard it is to be sober in a place where people party, and sometimes party hard. I wanted him to like Fire Island. I wanted him to like me.
I thought we’d work together, but we never did. The collaboration turned into silence. I felt like I was on a date with somebody that I liked, but it didn’t work out.
That was a few weeks before the Pines Party. It was one event I avoided for the longest time. This year, my friends Frank Libreto and Chad Herndon, who edit the journal, asked me to write an essay. Here’s the piece I wrote. It was published a few weeks ago on my 56th birthday.
* * *
2026 Pines Party Community Journal: Alter Ego
The Sign Keeps Disappearing
When this sandbar was carved into plots in the 1950s, the first thing visitors saw was a sign: Welcome to Fire Island Pines. A Family Community. It was more warning than welcome, with concerns about riotous parties, bikinis, and public exhibitionism. Thankfully, the Pines Party embodies all three.
The sign kept disappearing on weekends. By the time I arrived in 1993 for a Lambda Legal fundraiser, it was gone. The Pines became what it was always meant to be: ours.
Each spring when the ferry returns, the shoreline has changed again.
We don’t stumble onto the Pines. We arrive here with purpose. The dunes shift and the shoreline moves, so what felt like solid ground last September might be underwater by Memorial Day. Out here, we learn to read the landscape as something alive rather than fixed.
In the worst years of the AIDS epidemic, our community came here to mourn and dance together. It was our own form of defiance.
I spent many weekends in the Pines with my friend Jason Worth. He was a New York housing court judge, one of the first openly HIV-positive judges in the country. He was on the board of CRIA, the AIDS research organization where I worked. Jason invited me out to the small house he rented. It had the musty smell of every summer rental out here. Jason and I would sometimes spend weekends sharing a joint and laughing about Barney the Purple Dinosaur. Not long after, Jason was gone.
The Pines Party began in 1999, after protease inhibitors had arrived. The dying had slowed. The work had not.
I know the distance between a fight and its resolution. At nineteen, in 1990, I was expelled from the Boy Scouts of America for being gay. Lambda and I took that fight all the way to the Supreme Court. I wanted to be at those early Pines Parties. Suing an American icon, I knew better than to be photographed letting go.
I lost my case by a single vote. Then a grassroots movement grew. Today, Scouting is inclusive in ways that once seemed inconceivable: gay kids, girls, and trans kids. The federal government now wants trans kids out. The Supreme Court already gave that vote to the Scouts.
This is what regression looks like. It rarely announces itself. It erodes, a sign that keeps reappearing. Rights are not trophies placed on a shelf. You do not win them and move on. You hold them. Holding requires people, money, vigilance, and joy. Celebration is not a reward for when the fight is over. To stand on this beach with these people, exactly as we are, is what we must fight to keep.
So, this weekend: flirt with a stranger or two and tell them about a cause worth fighting for. Then find the organization doing that work and put something real behind it. Lambda has been mine for thirty years. Yours may be different. Find it.
When we come back next summer, the shoreline will have shifted again. The ground under this sandbar is always moving. That is not a reason to stop standing on it. It is a reason to stand together.
Here are a few more things I couldn’t fit in those five hundred words.
Fire Island is a place of privilege. The barriers to entry are exceedingly high, and I won’t pretend otherwise. It’s a resort island with boats and beach houses. It’s not most people’s idea of a refuge, and for too long it was a white, upper middle-class, gay, male enclave. But the Pines I know now is diversifying every season, and it’s only getting better. More women. More trans people and more people of color. Every weekend young people take the ferry out here to see what the fuss is about. There’s the Doll Invasion, a thriving art community, and then there are people who spend the whole weekend playing beach volleyball.
Here is what the Pines does for me. I come out here to recharge. I wear nail polish on the island that I hesitate to wear back in any city. I embrace my femininity without fear. I’m freer, sillier, and nobody ever bats an eyelash, and if they do, I just don’t care. There’s a sadness or longing that takes over me when I take the ferry back to Sayville.
So no, the Pines isn’t for everyone. It’s not perfect. No place is. But I stayed away from that party for too long because of what I thought it said about me. If the Pines has ever made you feel unwelcome, I understand better than most.
And if Fire Island is never going to be your place, I hope you’ll find somewhere that brings you joy, queer joy. Find that place you can be bold or quiet, sober or decadent, and embrace the parts of yourself you were taught to hate and be ashamed of. My partner and I love to share the island with those who have never been here before. People who don’t feel welcome at first or don’t have the means to get here. Since I only know how to sous vide a burger or two, our favorite guests are those who want to be family.
I guess you could tell how much I love Fire Island. Maybe it’s not your vibe. Where do you find your people, your voice, your community?
Thanks for reading and sharing.
James



So well said, James. I loved learning more about your deep bond with the ever evolving island and its community, while also understanding why others may feel differently about it. Your love and determination to protect and strengthen our community are inspiring. Lovely piece, thanks for sharing 💕
such a gorgeous piece! I've had great experiences with friends in the Pines but lately my husband and I have spent more quality time in Cherry Grove and found it's more our vibe. probably because it allows me to embrace my inner leabian (something that the gay boys don't always understand about me). so glad our mutual friend Michael Volpatt put us in touch and hoping we figure out a way to collaborate soon!